Friday, 14 November 2014

PART 2 (II) (Continuation) - THE NEW COMPANIES ACT

PART 2(ii) – CONTINUATION

I received a message (FB Inbox) telling me to express in the simplest form so that the ordinary layman can understand the Law.  

I’ll try my best  to do that while maintaining what the law actually try to say and avoiding changing the true meaning/definition attached to it. 

I am torn between the two world and may have to use more stroke/forward slash (“/”) and  parenthesis/Bracket all the way through.



4)  COMMON SEAL 

The current Companies Act requires a company to have common seal for the execution of document by affixing company’s common seal along with its authorized signatory.

The proposed new Companies Act makes common seal an optional requirement. 

If a company decide to have a common seal, the provision of the law must be observed and thus execution of documents can be done by affixing common seal as provided in the company’s constitution OR execution of document can be done by at least two person of which having been granted authority by the board. 

If the company has only one director, execution of document can be done singly in the presence of witness.

Common seal becomes an optional  requirement and thus save cost and time of company.



5)  COMPANY NAME

Currently, company’s name must be approved by the registrar. Name cannot be similar to any existing company’s name and Name must be reserved (s.22(6))

The proposed law requires that company’s name must be approved and it cannot be identical to any other existing name.

Reservation of name is now an optional matter. If the proposed name is not available, The Registrar has the power assign specific expression for it.

These changes are made to simplify the procedures involving company naming.



RESHAPING THE BOARD (BOARD OF DIRECTORS) TOWARDS BOARDROOM /MEETING EXCELLENCE


DEFINITION OF DIRECTORS

Section 4 of the current Companies  Act defines director to includes any person occupying the position of director of a corporation by whatever name called and includes a person in accordance with whose directions or instructions the directors of a corporation are accustomed (familiar/used to) to act and an alternate or substitute director

The proposed new law defines director to include any person occupying the position of director of a corporation by whatever name called and includes a person in accordance with whose directions or instructions majority of the directors of a corporation are accustomed (familiar/used to) to act and an alternate or substitute director

That is it.  By inserting the word “majority of” reshaped the boardroom. The provision clarifies (explains) the definition of “shadow directors” by clarifying that a person is deemed  (believed/considered/supposed)  to be director if the majority of directors act in accordance to his direction or instructions.



DIRECTOR

Section 122. Directors

(1)  Every company shall have at least two directors, who each has his principal or only place of residence within Malaysia.

(2)  No person other than a natural person of full age shall be a director of a company.


The proposed new law

Every private company shall have at least one directors, and every public company must have at least two directors who must ordinarily resides in Malaysia

And Directors must be at least 18 years old.


The rationale behind this is to facilitate ease of doing business by allowing private companies to have only one director and retaining the requirement for public companies to have at least two directors to safeguard the interest of the public and that the minimum age for a person to be appointed as director is 18 years.



PERSONS CONNECTED (HAVING TIES/RELATION) WITH DIRECTOR

Now fasten you seat belt. It gets complicated now :)


Existing Company Law

Who is called person(s) connected with directors?


Person connected with director

“a member of that director’s family” shall include his spouse, parent, child (including adopted child and step-child), brother, sister and spouse of his child, brother or sister.

“a director” is deemed to have control in a body corporate if he holds more than 15% of the issued shares or the voting power or able to control the board of the body corporate.


The proposed law

Person connected with director

“a member of that director’s family” means his spouse, parent, child (including adopted child and step-child, brother, sister and spouse of his child, brother or sister.

“a director” is deemed to have control in a body corporate if he holds more than 20% of the issued shares or the voting power or able to control the board of the body corporate.

The changes is indicated in the bold letter.

The changes are made to the above clauses in order to clarify that family members of a director is consisted of only those falling within the category and also to clarify as to when director is deemed to have control over a body corporate.

The controlling interest is increased from 15%-20%



To be continued



Mohdarismail
Company Secretarial Practitioner

Thursday, 13 November 2014

PART 2 - THE NEW COMPANIES ACT MALAYSIA

PART 2

THE NEW COMPANIES ACT

The corporate Law Reform initiative was made by the Suruhanjaya Syarikat Malaysia (SSM)  to repeal the current Companies Act 1965.

The proposed Companies Bill was drafted on the Reports issued by the Corporate Law Review Committee (CLRC) and  Accounting Issues Consultative Committee (AICC)

The review take into account recommendations made by the World Bank Reports namely the development in related laws such as capital market and Banking legislation.

The four(4) years review by the Corporate Law Review Committee has issued 12 consultative Papers.

The Corporate Law Review Committee’s Final report was issued in 2008 comprising of 188 recommendations on wide raging aspects from issues relating to Incorporation to issues on Companies winding-up and Its final report was completed and was submitted in 2011.

In July 2013 Public consultation on the drafted Companies Bill was conducted by the SSM and the Bill is expected to be tabled in Parliament in 2014.


WHAT IS THE IMPACT OF THE PROPOSED NEW COMPANIES ACT?

It was reported that the Law drafted helps enhancing the internal control, corporate governance and corporate responsibility.

It helps to facilitate starting a business as well as reduce the cost of doing it, simplification of compliance on provision and provides flexibility in managing the affairs of companies.


HERE COMES THE REVOLUTION OF STARTING BUSINESS IN MALAYSIA



1) SINGLE MEMBER

The current Company Law provides the minimum number of two(2) person, natural or otherwise as members and directors of a company.

With the CLRC recommendation , a company can be incorporated by a single member (person) and that single member can also be the single director of the company.

Nevertheless, Public company must have at least two(2) directors.

The rationale is to provide ease of doing business by facilitating entry with minimum requirement.

We are used to having meeting of at least 2 members and or directors. Any lesser, meeting cannot exist.  

With the new Company law,  a single person can meet on his own (Can decide and agree or otherwise, at his own whim and fancies :)



2)   MEMORANDUM & ARTICLES OF ASSOCIATION 


The existing Company Law requires company to have memorandum of association and the option of having articles of association and in default Table A will be Applicable.

The New Companies Act makes the above optional.  A company may adopt company’s constitution after its incorporation.

However,  companies Limited by guarantee is still required to have constitution at the point of  incorporation

The rationale again begs to ease of doing business. In the case of Companies Limited by Guarantee, company’s constitution is still required so that public can inspect the object of the company.



3)  CERTIFICATE OF REGISTRATION 

Section 16(4) of the existing law says that the certificate of registration issued is conclusive evidence of incorporation of a company.

With the new Companies Act,  NOTICE of registration is conclusive evidence and certificate of incorporation is optional. If you still need it, you can buy at your own cost from SSM.

The rationale behind this is still about ease of doing business and simplification of  incorporation process.

Now, what effect does the above proposal has on incorporation?

The effect of incorporation in the existing law is that a company is a body corporate and capable of suing and being sued, having perpetual succession and a common seal with power to hold land S.16(5)

With the proposed new companies Act the effect of incorporation is that a company is a body corporate WITH LEGAL PERSONALITY separate FROM ITS MEMBER and have the FULL CAPACITY TO UNDERTAKE ANY BUSINESS activities.

What derived here are the ENTRENCHMENT OF SEPARATE LEGAL ENTITY and UNLIMITED CAPACITY CONCEPTS which is not confined to object clause as currently used  in other leading jurisdiction.


To be continued...



Mohdarismail
Company Secretarial Practitioner


The Malaysian Corporate Law Reform Program of the Suruhanjaya Syarikat Malaysia (SSM)

PART 1

The Malaysian Corporate Law Reform Program of Suruhanjaya Syarikat Malaysia (SSM) began end of 2003 when the review of the Companies Act 1965 was initiated as part of Suruhanjaya Syarikat Malaysia’s (SSM) strategic direction in facilitating the development of a conducive and dynamic business and regulatory environment for Malaysia. 

Suruhanjaya Syarikat Malaysia (SSM) established the Corporate Law Reform Committee (CLRC) to spearhead the review of the Companies Act 1965 with the objectives 

(1) to create a legal and regulatory structure that will facilitate business; and

(2) to promote accountability and

(3) protection of corporate directors and members taking into account the interest of other stakeholders, in line with international standards  to reviewing and recommending changes to the Companies Act 1965.

The SSM recognizes the need to review the Companies Act 1965 to reflect the current and future needs of the business environment at the same time to undertake a fundamental review of the current legislative policies on corporate law in order to propose amendments that are necessary for corporate and business activities to function in a cost effective, consistent, transparent and competitive business environment in line with international standards of good corporate governance.


The scope of review of the corporate law reform Program is to carry out an extensive review of core company law governing the formation, management and termination of companies;

Although there are various laws and statutes that may affect a company’s business operations, the primary source of company law and the main statute on company law that determines the

(1) company’s formation,

(2) the rules governing the relationship between participants in companies (shareholders, directors and other officers of the company, and sometimes employees) and between the company and its participants (in particular,

(3) rules relating to

(a) share capital,
(b) members rights,
(c) directors’ duties and
(d) other matters relating to the management of companies) and
(e) termination of a company is the Companies Act 1965.

As legal entities, albeit with artificial legal personalities, companies are subject to the law in the same way as a legal person.

This means that laws such as contract law, tort law, environmental law etc, apply to companies, sometimes with such necessary modification to take account of the fact that companies are artificial persons.

These laws are applicable because a company does not operate in a vacuum and must rely on other external relationships to carry on business.

The fact that these laws apply to companies does not make them part of what is generally considered as "company law".

Therefore, although such laws are important for a company’s business, they will not be the main focus of the review;

The review will consider law reform initiatives that are being conducted internationally, notably the UK Company Law Review "Modern Company Law for a Competitive Economy".

The approach is to adapt and refine these international initiatives to suit the Malaysian corporate and business environment;

The scope of review will cover the current law and practice on core company law issues with the aim of reducing compliance cost in general and in particular for private companies.

This approach will be adopted by all the working groups particularly in relation to company formation and simplification of the reporting obligations to ease the administrative burdens imposed upon companies.

It is anticipated that there may be recommendations or draft legislative texts that will provide rules for private companies with additional or different provisions for public companies.

This was the approach of the UK Company Law Review and the Singapore Company Legislation and Regulatory Framework Committee (CLRFC);

The focus given to reduction of compliance cost for companies will necessarily require a review of the administrative structure of SSM as the current regulatory authority administering the Companies Act 1965.

The review will also consider the existing forms of business organizations in Malaysia and whether these are adequate to enable Malaysian companies and businesses to be competitive.

It is anticipated that the outcome of the review will enable corporate and business activities in Malaysia to function in a cost-effective, consistent and competitive business environment;


An important aspect of core company law is corporate governance.

The current law and practice on corporate governance focus on the relationship between various corporate participants and directors’ accountability. However the two main approaches in the corporate governance debate on the issue of directors’ accountability are the shareholder theory and the stakeholder theory.

The shareholder theory considers that directors have a duty to consider shareholders’ interests in company’s management whilst the stakeholder theory allows, or requires directors to consider the interests of other persons who are involved in a company’s management for example creditors and employees.

SSM takes note of these theories in their review but will be guided by the shareholder theory whilst taking account of the interests of other stakeholders.

The scope of the review will include, amongst others, the domestic and international developments on corporate governance and its impact on the appropriate legal and regulatory structure for company law.

The corporate governance debate also considers the link between statutory and non-statutory standards of corporate conduct.

In Malaysia, the Report of the Finance Committee on Corporate Governance and the Malaysian Code on Corporate Governance are the two authoritative documents which will also be considered in the review;

Codes of conduct and codes of best practices as well as self-regulation are now considered as complementary to statutory regulation. The review will take this into account to determine and ascertain the boundary of the law and self-regulation on company operations and decision-making in general and on corporate governance in particular. The question of the boundary between law and self-regulation will also relate to the issue of sanctions and enforcement, particularly in determining the appropriate mix of enforcement action;


When the Companies Act 1965 was first enacted, the only corporate regulatory authority was the Registrar of Companies.

Presently, the main corporate regulators in Malaysia are the SSM, the SC and Bursa Malaysia. However, the current enforcement and investigation powers given to the three regulators often overlap since there has never been a systematic and coherent revision of the overlaps, conflicts and duplication.

Because of this, the scope of review will consider identifying the activities of the regulatory authorities, the overlaps in the current enforcement and investigation powers and determining whether enforcement actions and rule making authority may be reallocated especially in relation to the appropriate mix of legal and self-regulatory rules to secure compliance; and

The focus on modernization of core company law would not be complete without reviewing the impact of Information and Communication Technology (ICT) on company law.

Company law, to a large extent, relies on dissemination of and access to information.

The review of the development in ICT will form an integral part of the reform process.

The scope of the review includes the recognition of the new technologies in business, its use and potential abuses and the safeguards that need to be built into the legal and regulatory structure to accommodate the new technologies.

The impact of ICT on company law will be considered by all Working Groups based on the approach that the legal and regulatory structure should facilitate the use of new technologies, be flexible to changes in technology and maintain integrity and security of information.

Very soon the Bill  that came with some 188 recommendations will be tabled in Parliament.

I will go into the details on the 188 recommendation one by one in part 2.


Mohdar Ismail
(Writing in my capacity as Company Secretarial Practioner for the past 23 Years.)

Sunday, 10 August 2014

HANYA ADA SATU CARA DARI BEBERAPA KEADAH YANG ADA UNTUK CARI MH370

Selepas 5 bulan MH370 belum lagi dijumpai dan tidak meninggal kan apa-apa bukti kukuh kemana ianya menghilang.

Dari jam 12:41 pagi 8/12/2014 MH370 bertolak dari KLIA menghala ke Beijing China namum pada jam 1:21 segala hubungan terputus dan pesawat ti
dak dapat dikesan lagi.

Kalau ikut perkiraan "kaki lima" disitu putus hubungan maka di situlah jatuh pesawat tersebut.

Kesemua andaian selepas jam 1:21 pagi itu sampailah kesaat ini adalah andaian semata-mana, tanpa ada bukti yang kukuh.

Sehingga kini pihak tentera atau pihak kementerian pertahanan tidak pernah mengeluarkan kenyataan formal bahawa pesawat yang berpatah balik melintasi utara Semenanjung Malaysia itu adalah MH370.

Kenyataan yang paling hampir adalah melalui siaran Dokumentari TV1 yang menyatakan bahawa "MENGIKUT RADAR TENTERA," pesawat yang berpatah balik keatah barat melintasi Utara Semenanjung Malaysia adalah MH370.

Tidak ada terdapat mana-mana maklumat kesanan radar negara jiran yang juga boleh mengkonformasi bahawa apa yang dikesan dalam radar mereka adalah pesawat MH370.

Pesawat yang dikesan mana-mana radar itu boleh jadi Pesawat yang menyamar ID MH370 sama ada drone atau jet tentera atau pesawat penyamar yang lain walau pun pada suatu ketika Syarikat Satelit yang mempunyai satelit yang berlegar di angkasa Lautan Hindi mengistiharkan bahawa ianya menerima atau mengesan isyarat dari MH370 dan dikatakan mengarah ke selatan lautan Hindi tetapi sumber isyarat itu belum tentu dari MH370 itu sendiri.

Beberapa bulan kemudian Syarikat Satelit itu mengaku bahawa ada kemungkinan bahawa isyarat yang diterima oleh satelitnya itu berkemungkinan besar "bogus". Dalam kata lain bukan dari pesawat MH370 itu sendiri.

Kenapa Radar tentera Australia yang boleh mengesan 3000KM tidak dapat mengesan MH370 yang dikatakan menghala menghampiri Barat Australia? 

Kenapa Pengkalan Tenteri Amerika yang canggih lagi rahasia dipulau Degio Garcia di lautan Hindi yang digunakan sebagai pengkalan tentera semasa memerangi Iraq dan Afganistan itu tidak dapat mengesan MH370 atau duduk diam mengenai dengan nya.

Pesawat yang menghala ke barat pada pagi 8/3/2014 itu juga dikatakan melintasi Utara Semenanjung diantara Pulau Pinang dan Pulau Langkawi dan menara komunikasi telefon ada kesan "login" telefon bimbit yang dimiliki oleh salah seorang krew pesawat. Perkara ini juga tidak dapat disahkan oleh mana-mana pihak, Kononnya kesanan itu boleh berlaku pada ketika pesawat itu terbang pada altitut yang rendah dan dapat berhubung dengan menara telekomunikasi di pulau itu.

Satu hal lagi ialah, pada saat perkara itu berlaku (telefon binbit krew pesawat log ke menara telekomunikasi) adalah dalam jam 2.00 pagi dan pada saat itu, mengikut perkiraan kelajuan MH370, ianya sepatutnya sudah berada di utara Sumatra berdekatan dengan Acheh kecuali MH370 itu merayau-rayau berlegar diruang udara membuang masa sebelum sampai ke utara pulau sumatra maka masa login itu mungkin boleh berlaku pada masa kejadian itu berlaku.

Secara am peluang untuk MH370 terhempas kedalam air (Lau/Lautan) adalah 70% dan hanya 30% didaratan.

Hampir keseluruhan usaha telah digemblingkan keatas peluang 70% itu dan hampir tiada keatas yang 30% dan tumpuan adalah di kawasan tertentu di Barat. Australia walau pun tiada bukti kukuh yang diperolehi yang menunjukkan MH370 berakhir disitu.

Syarikat satelit juga mengeluarkan data satelit yang berkaitan dengan MH370. Dengan data tersebut semua dan sesiapa saja akan mendapat jawapan yang hampir sama tanpa mengira data itu sahih atau sebaliknya.


https://news.yahoo.com/australia-malaysia-reach-search-cost-sharing-deal-032942526.html


Monday, 26 May 2014

FOR THE FIRST TIME SINCE DISPEARENCE ON 8TH MARCH, MILITARY RADAR CONFIRMED THE AIRCRAFT WAS MAS FLIGHT MH370

On May 26, 2014 at 07:00 pm Radio Television Malaysia (RTM) viewed a documentary on flight MH370 over its TV1 Channel.

The documentary revealed that the Malaysian Military radar confirmed that the aircraft that made a turn back and flew over North Peninsula Malaysia into a westerly direction was in fact Malaysian Airlines Flight MH370.

It did not say who in the Military or anyone in authority said that. It simply says The Malaysian Military Radar.

This is the first time since its disappearance on the early morning of March, 8th 2014  that this information is revealed to the public 

MH370 - DATA OR THE REPORT ON DATA?

"The report on the raw satellite data from United Kingdom’s Inmarsat, used to trace the flight pattern of the missing Malaysia Airlines Flight MH370, would be released tomorrow. (27-05-2014)" said Hishamuddin.

Caution : It is just a report on the data and not the data itself. :)

“If there is any chance that the Immarsat data proves to be inconclusive, the experts will be asked to look at all the available data to determine if the search is being carried out in the correct area.”

Does that mean the report on the data that is forthcoming is not based on all the available data on MH370?  Which is inconclusive the data or the report?